Five years to get kids home faster
August 29, 2023 · Español
In July 2018 four young immigrants and their families sued the Office of Refugee Resettlement in the Eastern District of Virginia. The children were in federal custody even though parents or relatives were ready to take them home, and a new agreement between ORR and immigration enforcement meant that stepping forward as a sponsor could expose a family member to arrest. The case was J.E.C.M. v. Lloyd, before Judge Leonie Brinkema. I was one of the lawyers for the plaintiffs, alongside the Legal Aid Justice Center, which brought the case, and later the Southern Poverty Law Center.
The record is public, and the Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse keeps the docket. A few milestones:
- November 2018: the court let the core of the case go forward.
- April 2019: it certified two classes — the children, and the family members trying to sponsor them.
- Along the way: ORR rescinded the information-sharing policy that had frightened sponsors away, and a parallel nationwide case in California, Lucas R., produced an injunction requiring new protections.
- August 2023: with ORR having put the protections in place, nothing was left for the court to order, and it closed the case. Along the way it recognized that the children and their would-be sponsors have a constitutional interest in family unity. LAJC’s account has the result that mattered: reunification delays fell sharply.
Five years is a long time in a child’s life, and most of the credit belongs to the people who do this work every day — LAJC first among them. My firm’s write-up of the decision has the statement of counsel.
What I take from it: a well-built case can force the government’s hand on policy.